Notification
Go to Home All Tools Compare Glossary Blog Contact

SIP Plan Comparison

Compare two Systematic Investment Plans (SIP) side-by-side. Analyze expected returns, invested amounts, and wealth accumulation over time.

A SIP Scenario A

₹
%
Yrs

B SIP Scenario B

₹
%
Yrs
Plan A Maturity Value Final Corpus
₹0 Invested: ₹0
Plan B Maturity Value
₹0 Invested: ₹0
Verdict

Plan A wins by ₹0

Plan A yields more returns than Plan B.

Growth Comparison over Time
Plan A Plan B
Step-by-Step Guide

How to Use the SIP Plan Comparison Calculator

Compare two mutual fund Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) strategies side-by-side to discover how varying your monthly contribution, return rate, and time horizon accelerates wealth creation.

1

Input Monthly Installments

Enter your planned monthly investment amount for Plan A and Plan B (e.g., comparing ₹5,000/mo vs ₹10,000/mo) using the sliders or inputs.

₹500 to ₹10 Lakh+
2

Set Horizons & Expected CAGR

Input expected annual growth rates (e.g., 11% large cap vs 14% flexi cap) and desired tenure (1 to 30 years) for dynamic recalculation.

Live dynamic sync
3

Inspect Wealth Divergence

Analyze the interactive growth curves: observe how consistent contributions and compounding create massive terminal wealth differences in the later years.

Exponential curve
4

Review Matrix & Share

Review total capital invested vs capital gains in the comparison matrix below. Click Share to save or export your scenario.

1-Click link sharing

Mutual Fund Principle: The 15*15*15 Compounding Rule

Investing ₹15,000 monthly for 15 years at an expected 15% CAGR historically yields approximately ₹1 Crore (comprising ₹27 Lakh invested principal and ~₹73 Lakh compounded gains). Adding just 5 additional years (20 years total) triples the projected corpus to over ₹3 Crore!

Decision Guide

Comparing 2 SIP Plans: Which is Better?

In mutual fund investing, time in the market consistently beats timing the market. Discover whether increasing monthly contributions or extending duration builds larger terminal wealth.

When Higher Monthly SIP Wins

Best for shorter horizons & fixed-term financial targets

  • Reaches Goals Faster (<10 Yrs): Essential when saving for children's higher education or a house down payment with fixed deadlines.
  • Compensates for Lower Duration: High principal deployed upfront allows shorter timeframes to accumulate substantial capital.
  • Lower Reliance on High CAGR: Allows you to invest in safer large-cap/hybrid funds rather than taking excessive volatility risks.
Hits targeted milestones rapidly

When Longer Duration Wins

Best for retirement corpuses & generational wealth

  • Exponential Compounding Hockey Stick: Over 70% of total maturity wealth generates in the final 5–7 years of a 20-year SIP.
  • Minimal Monthly Budget Strain: A modest ₹5,000/month installment over 25 years can surpass a ₹15,000/month SIP run for only 10 years.
  • Neutralizes Market Cycles: Riding through multiple bull and bear phases unlocks full rupee cost averaging.
Unlocks maximum exponential compounding

Higher Monthly SIP: Pros & Cons

Advantages (Pros)
  • Achieves specific goal amounts in half the time.
  • Reduces exposure to long-term market volatility unpredictability.
Trade-offs (Cons)
  • Requires tight monthly cash discipline and higher committed outgo.

Longer Duration: Pros & Cons

Advantages (Pros)
  • Small monthly investments compound into multi-crore wealth.
  • Completely stress-free installment amount that survives job changes.
Trade-offs (Cons)
  • Requires staying invested across market crashes without panic redeeming.
Compounding Insights

4 SIP Realities Before You Compare

The 15*15*15 Rule

₹15,000/mo for 15 years at 15% yields ₹1 Crore. But continuing for just 5 more years (20 total) triples your corpus to ₹3 Crore! Time is the biggest multiplier.

Step-Up SIP Advantage

Increasing your SIP installment by 10% annually alongside salary increments generates up to 50–80% greater final corpus than a flat contribution.

12.5% LTCG Tax Slabs

Budget 2024 revised equity mutual fund Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) to 12.5% for gains above ₹1.25 Lakh per financial year. Factor this into net goals.

Rupee Cost Averaging

Bear markets are when SIPs shine brightest: your fixed debit buys more mutual fund units at discounted NAVs, supercharging future rebound gains.

Side-by-Side Plan Matrix

Live parameter comparison between SIP Plan A and Plan B

Metric Plan A Plan B Difference
Monthly Investment — — —
Expected Return Rate — — —
Tenure (Duration) — — —
Total Amount Invested — — —
Wealth Gained (Returns) — — —
Final Maturity Value — — —
Case Studies

Real-World Comparison Scenarios

Realistic investment scenarios showing how contribution size and timeframe interact

Scenario 1 12% Expected CAGR
Time vs Money

₹5,000 (25 Yrs) vs ₹10,000 (15 Yrs)

Aman starts early with ₹5,000/mo over 25 years. Karan starts 10 years later but doubles down with ₹10,000/mo over 15 years.

• Aman (₹5k for 25 Yrs): Invests ₹15L total. Final corpus = ₹94.88 Lakh.
• Karan (₹10k for 15 Yrs): Invests ₹18L total. Final corpus = ₹50.45 Lakh.
Key Takeaway: Aman invests ₹3 Lakh LESS capital but accumulates ₹44.43 Lakh MORE wealth due to an extra 10 years of compounding!
Scenario 2 ₹15,000/mo • 20 Yrs
Index vs Mid-Cap

Nifty 50 (12%) vs Mid-Cap (14%)

Ananya compares conservative Nifty 50 Index SIP (12% CAGR) against a higher-beta active Mid-Cap Fund SIP (14% CAGR).

• Plan A (12% Nifty Index): Invests ₹36L total. Maturity corpus = ₹1.50 Crore.
• Plan B (14% Mid-Cap): Invests ₹36L total. Maturity corpus = ₹1.97 Crore.
Key Takeaway: A 2% CAGR difference expands the final corpus by ₹47 Lakh over 20 years.
Good to know

Questions, answered

Quick answers about how this tool works.

A Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) is a method of investing a fixed sum of money regularly in mutual funds, allowing you to invest in a disciplined way and benefit from rupee cost averaging and compounding.

When comparing two SIP plans, analyze three key inputs: the monthly investment amount, the expected annual return rate, and the investment duration. The plan with a higher return rate or longer duration will build significantly more wealth due to compounding.

A higher expected return rate yields a larger final corpus but usually comes with higher market risk. High-return mutual funds (e.g., small-cap or sectoral funds) are highly volatile, whereas moderate-return funds (e.g., large-cap or index funds) are more stable.

Duration has the most significant impact on your final wealth due to compounding. Compounding gains speed up exponentially in the later years. Investing for 20 years instead of 10 years can yield triple or quadruple the final maturity value for the same monthly amount.

What do you need to work out next?

Search 278+ free tools by name, or pick a category below. Every one runs instantly in your browser — no signup, nothing to install.

More Finance tools
AI ADVISOR & COACH

Ask AI Advisor

Ask AI